's ending, in which powerless Mirabel saves the miracle, Encanto Subtly Revealed Its Mirabel Power Twist At The Beginning, Encanto's Unique First Makes A Disney Trend Much Darker. Encanto: Could Mirabel Become The Next Official Disney Princess? By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. @media(min-width:0px){#div-gpt-ad-remodelormove_com-medrectangle-4-0-asloaded{max-width:300px!important;max-height:250px!important}}if(typeof ez_ad_units!='undefined'){ez_ad_units.push([[300,250],'remodelormove_com-medrectangle-4','ezslot_11',155,'0','0'])};__ez_fad_position('div-gpt-ad-remodelormove_com-medrectangle-4-0');By taking out these frustrations and feelings of loneliness onto Mirabel and making her feel guilty and scared, Abuela can make Mirabel feel that she needs her and that she has not been completely abandoned by her daughter. Growing up in a small town in Catalonia, she witnessed the horrors of war firsthand, as her hometown was subject to bombings, suffering significant destruction. Mirabel had always been close to Abuela and looked up to her for guidance and wisdom, so finding out that Abuela had been keeping something so significant from them was shocking and unexpected. Loves talking rubbish about films and collecting crystals. Abuela was insistent on them having another child to add more powers to the family, as she was obsessed with her familys legacy and protecting the town through their unique abilities. They both lose their home. All rights reserved. Therefore, while she did contribute to the Madrigals problems, it would be unfair to solely blame her for the familys strife. Manage Settings Based on this definition, it is clear that Abuela is indeed gaslighting Mirabel in the story. Privacy Policy. She showered Mirabel with extra love and attention, and tried to make every moment special for her. She is the matriarch and the keeper of the familys magic, and she is also the one who decides which family members receive magical gifts. Mirabel hugged Abuela because she was overwhelmed with emotions that Abuela had been keeping a big secret from their family. For me to give you a precise and accurate answer, please provide me with the necessary context and details related to the question. In the beginning, Abuela acts like Mirabel is useless for not having a Advertisement Coins 0 coins Premium Powerups Explore Gaming While Abuela may not blame Mirabel for the familys breakdown, it is clear that she is deeply hurt by the situation and is struggling to come to terms with what has happened. Encanto has been a strong success for Disney in many ways, and one of the film's greatest strengths is how it underscores the value of family by pointing out that every member of the Madrigal family has value, with or without a magic gift. She was allowed to be evil which is not the same thing. this could mean that when mirabel failed to receive a gift, that the pressure the family, and isabela - specifically, was increased by alma. I disagree with people saying that she was evil, she wasn't evil. She plays an integral role in the Madrigal family and their journey to restore their magical legacy. She puts an undue amount of pressure on herself to keep the family going in times of crisis by performing the role of a strong figurehead, trying to overcompensatewith a sense of power and control becauseshe had none over her husband's death. But why? To answer the question of whether Abuela is gaslighting Mirabel, we need to first understand what gaslighting means. Encanto Ending: Does Mirabel Have A Power Now? Additionally, Abuela could be biased against Mirabel because she was born out of wedlock, which is heavily frowned upon in traditional Latino families. Because he let down Abuela? If Abuela did something that greatly affected Mirabels life or caused her a lot of pain, it may be harder for Mirabel to forgive her. Here, Mirabel was the only one who confronted the Abuela. They watched and did nothing despite acknowledging that they were sad and pressured. Archived post. Disney's "Encanto" but its just abuela being mean to mirabel in that Much like Mirabel, Abuela doesn't actually have a magic power. This trauma may play a part in why she doesn't warm to Mirabel. You may hold the miracle of the encanto but I . They could have talked with her in a serious tone, and tell her to stop putting pressure over them. Mirabel also understood that Abuela was trying to protect her, even though her methods were misguided. It is important to recognize signs of gaslighting and seek help if you or someone you know is experiencing it. this results in isabela getting the majority of alma's love and attention, where luisa is taken for granted and mirabel is the family scapegoat. It began with her and Pedro, and it continues through her keeping of the candle and her love for all of her children and grandchildren. By possibly sharing the same gift, the reflection of herself in her granddaughter brings about the residue ofthisunresolved trauma. Through an unexplained miracle, Alma's candle attained magical qualities, keeping them safe from their pursuers and building a sentient house Casita for them. It is obvious that Abuela is incredibly lonely, and her own daughter, Mirabels mother, has largely moved away and left her to manage on her own. 5. Some of our partners may process your data as a part of their legitimate business interest without asking for consent. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. I Saw My Abuela in Encanto's Abuela Alma - We are Mitu No, Abuela was not the villain in Encanto. if you have another idea, feel free to leave them in the comments! Yes, Mirabel eventually forgave Abuela. Privacy Policy. At the beginning of the story, it is clear that Abuela is trying to punish Mirabel for sacrificing a part of her education to help support her family financially during hard times. Encanto fan suggests harsh reason Mirabel doesn't have a gift Whether Abuela Madrigal says sorry or not depends on various factors such as her personality, values, culture, upbringing, and the context of the situation. Of course the abuela wasn't going to stop her pressure since no one had a serious talk with her. Forgiveness is a personal decision, and it is up to Mirabel to determine if she is capable of forgiving Abuela. View complete answer on encanto.fandom.com What was everyone's power in Encanto? What is Mirabel's gift in Encanto? All the family Madrigal's powers Instead, it's the family Madrigal coming together, loving one another, and being happy that is the true magic that sustains their miracle. In some stories, Abuela is a beloved family figure who acts as a mother or grandmother figure while in others Abuela is a leader or matriarch. @media(min-width:0px){#div-gpt-ad-remodelormove_com-box-3-0-asloaded{max-width:728px!important;max-height:90px!important}}if(typeof ez_ad_units!='undefined'){ez_ad_units.push([[728,90],'remodelormove_com-box-3','ezslot_3',175,'0','0'])};__ez_fad_position('div-gpt-ad-remodelormove_com-box-3-0');Without male presence in the home Abuelas husband has since passed away loneliness can be a hard pill to swallow. The candle's magical flame never goes out and has gifted most of the family members with magical powers. Her demeanor insults Isabela's true nature, suffocating her epiphany. Mirabel was the only member from the family who had the guts to confront her about her awful attitude. The actual villain in Encanto was a group of shamans and their leader, El Rey, who wanted to use the special powers of Abuelas grandchildren to unbalance nature and bring a new age of darkness and destruction. She expresses her frustrations through making cruel and hurtful comments and belittling Mirabel which leads her to develop a low self-esteem. 1 day ago, by Eden Arielle Gordon This form of emotional abuse is a serious issue, as it can have long-lasting effects on a persons mental health and well-being. However, it also adds an interesting angle to Mirabel's story. Courtney is a TV/Movie Features writer for Screen Rant who recently graduated with a BA in English Literature. "I have not heard Mirabel utter a word, Alma Madrigal," said the elderly woman with a cracked voice "I have only heard you, yelling like a banshee. Another family member whose power is not immediately evident is Abuela Alma. This thread is archived New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast 282 77 comments Best milkshakescookies 1 yr. ago As Abuela addressesher past, she finally softens towards Mirabel. Let's Investigate, Dua Lipa's Sister Rina Is Making Her Acting Debut, Ashley Park's Star Turn Anchors the Hilarious and Absurd "Joy Ride", We Found the Best Merch For Your "Barbie" and "Oppenheimer" Double Feature, What to Know About "Indiana Jones and the Dial of Destiny"'s Basil Shaw, Why Indiana Jones's Son, Mutt Williams, Isn't in "The Dial of Destiny", Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information. Published Jan 23, 2022 Isabela Madrigal was arguably Encanto's most annoying character, but was her bizarre behavior justified? thank you for reading! The theory, posted on Reddit, goes some years back to explain why Mirabel didnt get a gift, suggesting that Abuela pushed Julieta and Agustn to have a third child, even though they were already happy with two. Grandma had wanted a daughter for a long time, but was unable to have one of her own. Mirabel's Secret Gift Explains Why Abuela Doesn't Actually - YouTube This would also be consistent with how Encanto cleverly unwraps generational trauma by combining history and fantasy. Mirabel didn't get a gift because that would have rewarded Abuela for her manipulation, as she pushed for Mirabel to exist just to add more powers to the family. Madrigals Read Mama Bear - Chapter 24 - Archive of Our Own the hug also demonstrated that family loyalty and love could transcend secrets and difficult times. Discover abuela being mean to mirabel stich 's popular videos - TikTok so their acknowledgement of just how much courage mirabel had is an admission of the role they played in pushing mirabel to this point, and them taking back the previous notion that mirabel was an unwelcomed nuisance. AbuelaS traumas are a combination of her childhood experiences, her husbands death, and her responsibilities as the Madrigal family leader. ""And then Tio tried to hide his rat but Tia didn't believe him so she tackled him," Mirabel explained happily to her amused Abuela." Mirabel bit her lip. Published Feb 6, 2022 Mirabel Madrigal is Abuela Alma's eventual replacement in Disney's Encanto, and one meaningful theory from the film finally explains why. The problem is all the family. However, through the events of the film, she comes to realize the significance of letting go of the past and trusting the next generation to carry on the Madrigal legacy. More:Encanto's Unique First Makes A Disney Trend Much Darker. However, there may be more to Abuela than some viewers realize. She never hated Mirabel, she just assumed she was causing trouble and acting out when she wasn't. Furthermore, Abuela blames Mirabel for her own unhappiness and tries to control her behavior by manipulating her emotions. It is unclear if Mirabel will take over for Abuela. Archived post. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. so, of course, siblings can have incredibly petty reasons to hate one another. harsh on other members of the Madrigal family. Surprisingly, Mirabel wasn't granted a gift like those of her relatives by the end of Encanto, but it can be argued that her gift was different as shes on her way to taking over leadership of the family. notes;--- 1. Mirabel wanting to be part of the family put her in everyone's way. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Isa is an angry person who bottles up her own resentments and anxieties to the point of abusing her youngest, ungifted sister. The reason behind Mirabels lack of a gift (or at least, powers similar to her familys) might be more complex than it seems. When Mirabel attempts to protect her sister and explain, Abuela claims that Mirabel is ruining the family because of her jealousy. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Abuela is mean to Mirabel because she takes out her frustrations from her life onto her. @media(min-width:0px){#div-gpt-ad-remodelormove_com-leader-3-0-asloaded{max-width:250px!important;max-height:250px!important}}if(typeof ez_ad_units!='undefined'){ez_ad_units.push([[250,250],'remodelormove_com-leader-3','ezslot_19',164,'0','0'])};__ez_fad_position('div-gpt-ad-remodelormove_com-leader-3-0');The trauma she endured throughout her lifetime deeply affected her, and she never fully overcame it. Ultimately, she is a well-rounded, non-evil character who is just trying to make her family happy. Her trauma has led to her becoming a rigid and traditional leader, who struggles to adapt to change and let go of the past. Thus, Abuela's power and responsibility are to keep her family together. By symbolically passing the candledown to Mirabel as Abuela's replacement, it signals Abuela being ready to accept her past and her future, which benefits all members of the Madrigals in Encanto. Why is Abuela so disappointed in Mirabel when she also doesn - Reddit I don't understand why Isabela gets surprised when Mirabel - Reddit It may take time and effort on both sides to rebuild trust and repair the relationship, but it is possible for forgiveness to occur. It is important to note that forgiveness does not necessarily mean forgetting or excusing the actions that were taken, but rather, it is about finding a way to move forward and heal from the hurt. The embrace was a physical manifestation of the love they shared, and it was a way for Mirabel to show that, regardless of Abuelas secret, she was still their beloved family member who was worthy of love and respect. 8 clues in 'Encanto' that prove Mirabel is supposed to be the next Abuela A hint at Abuela's "power" reveals itself during Antonio's ceremony (where we learn his power is talking to animals). Abuela is the matriarch of the Madrigal family and the keeper of their magical home. She is the eldest daughter of Agustin and Julieta Madrigal, and the older sister of Luisa and Mirabel. It is unclear if Abuela purposely chose not to give Mirabel a gift. we never see when alma began to project onto isabela, but with isa being her first grandchild born, there is plausible reason to think that it began at an early age for isa. Alma Madrigal (often referred to as Abuela) is the deuteragonist of Disney 's 2021 animated feature film, Encanto. Through the healing process and their developing relationship, Mirabel and Abuela started to understand one another, and the two were able to build trusting and supportive relationship. Is Abuela the reason Mirabel didnt get a gift? If Mirabel had gotten a gift, it could have only served as a distraction for Abuela, and she might not have processed her past. Huge fan of Fozzie Bear. Sometimes on rare occasions it does, especially if your house ends up in shambles or someone gets hurt because of your pride. To put it simply/harshly, the theory argues that Abuela didn't really think Mirabel had a defining trait that could lead to a specific magical gift. So, no, an apology scene is not "unrealistic". we know that isabela is afraid of alma and what would happen, should she be perceived as anything less than perfect - as seen at the end of "what else can i do" - but by this point, all the resentment towards mirabel seemed to have gone away. They not only laid the entire groundwork for the journey of the Madrigals, but also gave weight to Encanto's overarching narrative by connecting it to Colombia's real history. However, when Mirabel, the only Madrigal member without a special gift, discovers that the magic that holds their family together is weakening, she seeks to find a way to save it. All rights reserved. Looking at Mirabel, she perhaps sees and relives the trauma that happened years ago when the magic began. In addition, some cultures and social norms place a greater emphasis on apologies and forgiveness than others. Encanto characters watch Encanto! - Chapter 6 - Archive of Our Own Abuela, played by actor of the voice of Rita Moreno, was a loving and dedicated grandmother who only wanted what was best for her family. It's changed because Mirabel stood up for herself and for her family. She created an environment where her children felt ignored and underappreciated, leading one of her daughters, Luisa, to leave and estrange herself from the family. In the movie Encanto, Abuela, the matriarch of the Madrigal family, tries to protect her familys miracle-giving magic with a heavy hand.