There's a point in the song where the music indicates this where she needs to belt. Sebastian is speaking but when his words no longer work he sings. The kids are asked to present a perfect image, and this comes at the detriment of their mental health. The entire movie seems to be about a crisis of faith, wherein the family loses the miracle not because of Abuela's power hunger, or the family's interpersonal problems, but because they lost their faith in it. Courtney Reed is currently a List Writer for Screen Rant based in Atlanta. The blame lies not only with Abuela, but also the kid's parents who are privy to the pressure as well, however, they do nothing to change things. In fact, Encanto feels more like a play than anything else. https://tinyurl.com/56eadf84 WritersJeremy: https://twitter.com/cinemasins Chris: Aaron: https://twitter.com/aarondicer Jonathan: https://twitter.com/samloomis13 Dene: https://twitter.com/DeneeSaysIan: https://twitter.com/whittsinned Daniel:Other LinksDiscord: https://www.discord.gg/cinemasins Reddit: https://www.reddit.com/r/CinemaSins/ Jeremy's Book: https://cinemasins.com/book Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/cinemasins/ The Problem with "Encanto" | Psychology Today From its catchy songs and brilliantly subtle details to its resonant story, the award-winning musical has captured the hearts and minds of millions. A broken history got them there, but its a miracle that theyre still there regardless. The Encanto Fandom Is The New Hamilton Fandom - YouTube In addition to interactions among the fans, the creators of the film have interacted with them, sharing fun facts and production notes. These individuals were/are portrayed as the screw-ups and unreliable of the family. The film needed a strong sense of the . Join Ian, Dene, and a crew of intrepid guests as they boldly explore everything they love and, naturally, everything wrong with the franchise that has dominated the final frontier for more than half a century. Also at the end of the movie it does magically appear that all of the family's dysfunction is fixed. While she herself has become a popular figure, her movie took immediate flak for its handling of race. I've gotta do so much before this proposal so I really don't have time to--, Luisa: I don't know anything about the magic fading and--. If nothing else, fans who were tricked by the misheard lyrics can rest assured knowing that they were deceived by none other than a simple linguistic theory and a process that even Hendrix couldn't escape from. The happiness portrayed in Encanto isnt just escapism, its defiance. And that's a big problem. Encanto, though, embraces those intricacies, . For example, when Isabella and Mirabel have their confrontation the song interrupts the actual emotion of the scene. So with all that said, Encanto feels like a step backwards. When compared to Luca, Encanto is a pretty weak entry for Disney to end 2021 on. I was really frustrated with the lack of actual acknowledgement or apologies. When Bruno has his vision about Mirabel needing to reconcile with Isabella I kind of laughed. Mistakes or inadequacies are always frowned upon. Encanto's Subtitle Problems, Explained Home Movie Features The Newest Encanto Controversy is a Classic Linguistics Dilemma By Ben Bishop Published Feb 16, 2022 Fans of Disney's Encanto have found some interesting discrepancies in the subtitles, stemming from a common linguistics issue. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. Bruno simply stated one day that weather looked like rain. Luisa's song is a great example. Published Apr 10, 2022 Luisa struggles with her gift earlier than the rest of the Madrigals in Encanto due to both high expectations and doubts about her powers and worth. If this were fiction, people would cease engaging with it because grimdark gets boring. In essence, she was the reason for the familys decaying structure from the inside and outside. Magical powers aside so much of Encanto is grounded in reality they could have just shot this in live action. My dad is 56 years old. These days, he can't write with his left hand anymore, but he does everything else with his left hand. You could have easily written half of them out of the plot and not skipped a beat. Key points. Log in, Enter Your Email Address To Get A Free Subscription To The CPR Newsletter, ring Brand Takes Another Hit with Encanto Box Office Nosedive, Stephen Frank's California Political News And Views, Tulare DA Warns of Bill to Release Worst-of-the-Worst Murderers After 25 Years, Truck Makers Pledge to Comply With New California Rules Phasing Out Gas-Powered Vehicles, A move from California to Texas could save a million dollars. The movement is so fluid and the lighting is excellent. Mirabel is essentially forced to bury her feelings and issues toward her sister in order to save the family's house, which is toxic as hell. Official /r/Disney 'Encanto' Discussion Thread [Spoilers Inside] - Reddit My problem with Encanto is that, despite the stark visual contrast to classic Disney movies with waif-thin, conventionally attractive women (which didn't bother me), Encanto does little to distinguish itself from recent Disney movies. Coco had many songs that Incorporated Spanish and the climax of the film was a song sung in Spanish. For Bruno, being a burden to his family is not something he could handle, so he removed himself from the family, going into hiding in a secret part of the Madrigal house. It was an undeniably visually striking film, with an amazing score. He reminded me of Cassandra from the Iliad, only having the opposite problem. After arguing throughout the whole movie about how to save the house and whos to blame for its impending destruction, the Madrigals ultimately have to accept that their miracle wasnt the magical house, or their magical gifts. Please enter a valid email and try again. Both of those films had a sense of scope that let the overall basic stories they were telling feel much more grandiose. 3. But.they're not everything. When she wants to help out before the reveal of Antonio's gift, everyone in the family (except Antonio, a literal child) tells her not to help, that she's just in the way. "There are so many layers, so many dynamics," Adelakun says. Isabela, who among other objectifications is being forced into a loveless marriage, wonders, What could I do if I just knew it didn't need to be perfect? The wounds caused by the Madrigals dysfunction go on and on. We didn't get enough Encanto! Set in the South American country of Colombia and featuring music by Lin-Manuel Miranda, Encanto is the 60th animated feature from Walt Disney Animation Studios. Encanto: 10 Worst Things Abuela Did To Her Family, Ranked - CBR The ending of Encanto let me perplexed because I didn't really know if I wanted them to have their power back. In Abuelas mind, Mirabel brought nothing but chaos and destruction to the family, and she made this known every time something went wrong. In Encanto, the fairytale fights with the fearful truth right up until the credits roll. The musical sequences feel more like music videos rather than an expression of anything the characters are thinking or feeling. Updated Jun 9, 2022 Each member of the Madrigal family with a special gift received it for a reason. Cast actual rappers to perform/write the rapping segments of your music Lin. Perhaps that would have forced them to focus on the story instead, who knows. When Mirabel says, If youre impressed imagine how I feel, we can safety conclude she feels profound pain. Yes this character who we have heard maybe ten lines from who they barely hinted at having any layers is now pivotal to the plot. The problem being : they change because they were wrong for being angry at the dad, ans not because they were wrong for being toxic with the kid, which is Problematic. Encanto finally solves a Disney villain formula problem - Polygon But by not having her sing it creates a distance between the audience and her emotionally. Thursday: Animated sins from the aughts.Which movie's sins should we count next?CinemaSins website https://www.cinemasins.com Channels--TVSins: https://www.youtube.com/c/TVSins/--MusicVideoSins: https://www.youtube.com/c/musicvideosins/--CommercialSins: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UChg9sWwaJ2TYqpaYqerY5BA --CinemaSins Podcast Network: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC5Nxj5dpHf2p7cN9qdUVEzA SinClub Members get MORE! Capybara? Most of the story takes place in one general setting. He didn't have a grip on reality, he pretended to be different people with different traits because he had nobody to rely to, he was so afraid of everything that he was doing all these rituals that superstitions insist ward off evil, he was pale and surely malnourished and never saw sun except for a few rays And, when by the end of the movie, he got the courage to stand up to his mother, the person who was the reason for his exile in the first place, fully expecting horrible consequences, in order to protect his niece, she gave him a hug (symbolic of her total embrace of him) and now it's all good. Posted February 23, 2022 | Reviewed by Gary Drevitch. I HAVE NEVER SEEN SUCH BULLSHIT! I hate to keep going back to much better films, but Moana and Coco were explorations of culture and identity through a hyper stylized method. By having something to fight against, it allowed the members of the family who weren't on the best terms to find something to fight against and realize the pettiness of their divide. Alma seemingly comes to a realization about Mirabels worth and her own shortcomings. He's quite literally the scapegoat! Her resilience to be there for her family, even through the mistreatment, makes Mirabel one of the most likable characters in the film. The Problem with The Encanto Fandom 24,551 views Jan 2, 2022 765 Dislike Share Save Lauren G 1.27K subscribers HAPPY NEW YEAR EVERYONE :) I hope you all have a great 2022 I had wanted to make. I grew up in a dysfunctional family, and at first I was able to identify with the dynamic going on, but then it just completely misrepresents what being in a dysfunctional family is like. Become a member of the SinClub to interact LIVE with them every week! And yet, I walked out (rather: closed the tab) with a hole in my soul. Generational Trauma Being Passed Down Since Encanto reminded me a lot of Coco, I couldn't help but compare . The cartoon is ultimately a tragedy that provides a counterexample to healthy family relationships. However, theres no denying that there is power in seeing your own world elevated to the ranks of iconic fairytales and animated blockbusters. That. You can post now and register later. 'Encanto': Therapists ARE talking about Bruno -- and other - CNN As a child, he got the shit kicked out of him because he was left handed, and was gaslighted into thinking that it was for the best, that he was "disciplined properly". When my dad grew up and had his own child (me), he would sometimes hit me (a slap on the arm) so that I could "learn discipline properly". I do not forgive. Moana found its heart in the amalgam of cultures it was portraying. She has to sleep in a nursery. However, Mirabel always made it her mission to assist and be of help to the family in any way she could. The natural progression from talking to singing doesn't work for a good chunk of the musical numbers. The magic of the Encanto has blessed every child in the family with a unique gift from super strength to the power to healevery . I've gotta get the donkeys. Posted February 23, 2022 | Reviewed by Gary Drevitch. Mirabel is 15, so not an adult yet, but most definitely not an infant, but she's treated like one at all times. It crescendos but she does not. It feels like the Latina version of A Friend Like Me. But I'm probably read too much. Kind of like the immense social stigma women with amenorrhea (still not having a menstrual period by age 15, or not having one for other reasons) face. With Surface Pressure and What Else Can I Do, dialogue would have actually worked better for most of that. The animated film gets to the heart of the Colombian experience that many might overlook. RELATED: The 10 Funniest Underrated Moments In Disneys Encanto, According To Reddit. Letting Mirabel be the emotional lead in this sequence would have been so much more impactful. The genocidal conquest by Spain, as well as the subsequent decade-long independence process, set the stage for a very messy 200 years of history. Even if the issue is having a character on screen sing in Spanish the whole time you could have worked in lyrics so she is expressing herself less ambiguously. Published Mar 3, 2022 In Disney's Encanto, Mirabel Madrigal embarks on a journey for answers and faces many harsh realities. And if initial reactions here in Colombia are any indication, the film is resonating. This desperate need for things to go her way leads Abuela to say some terrible things to Mirabel. In the process of deeply rooting the film in Colombian culture, whether through Lin-Manuel Mirandas well-researched music that spans all sorts of regional genres or the unique cast of characters meant to encompass a weird and disparate country, Encanto celebrates the diversity of Colombia, the happiness to be found in its art, its nature, its heritage, and, more than anything, its people. Narcissists do not feel empathy the way normal people do, they do not deem . Everything Wrong With Encanto In 17 Minutes Or Less - YouTube Nobody comes out of that mentally okay. Disney has proven they can create gorgeous animated films but the stories have been weak. She has to sleep in a nursery. Its about challenging that notion that we Colombians have to be miserable forever. Detailed explorations of some of Almas abuses can be found online (e.g. Yes I know it's essentially a fairy tale but usually in these movies we get some kind of rules or parameters. The integration is also a bit sloppy and for a minute I was waiting for Mirabel to ask 'why are you singing?' Disneys movie about our country couldnt overtly include our violent past and present. Posted February 23, 2022 | Reviewed by Gary Drevitch. The US took advantage of this and caused Panama to become independent from Colombia. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. Sure, Disney was probably avoiding details because theyd be too graphic or complicated for young viewers (or, more cynically, because they might be taken as a political statement). Colombias problems are so intrinsic that being aware of them from birth almost seems necessary to feel Colombian at all. Maybe. Luisa popping and locking to, what I'll generously call a Reggaeton song, took me out of the movie. Encanto: Original motion picture soundtrack. More than tugging at one's inner child, the Disney. The movie follows Mirabel as she sees that the house, their Casita, is starting to crack at the foundations, which her Abuela adamantly denies in an effort to maintain order. However, such fleeting and superficial admissions are common with abusers as they love-bomb their way into a honeymoon phase. Share. One second Abuela is screaming about how Bruno doesn't care about the family, the next second she hugs him as if she was missing him the whole time. For more information, please see our The movement is so fluid and each character feels incredibly vibrant and lived in. I'm not a fanboy but I'm also not a hater. A few years later, Moana was generally well-received, but suffered its own criticisms from Pacific Islander communities. Outside of Mirabel, Almo, Bruno and a few others most of the family is relegated to being side characters who are largely used for sight gags. It is because a new room is built when they get their powers, but as she never had hers, she has no new room to go. I had to lookup the lyrics to a couple songs to know what was being said. Even Luisa is shunted off to the side after her big number. Like the Madrigals, were each trying to deal with all this alone and realizing, perhaps through projects like Encanto, that maybe we dont have to. It has a wholesome story, beautiful animation, great music, and lovable characters that fans care for. Retrieved February 22, 2022, from https://www.cbr.com/encanto-worst-things-abuela-did-family-ranked/. So with all that said, why not have Alma actually sing Dos Orgulitas? It can either be great or feel like something meant for a meme. A weekly roundup of the best things from Polygon, By submitting your email, you agree to our, Disneys Encanto isnt just about representation its an act of defiance, Sign up for the 4. Is this the product of a multi-billion-dollar corporation thats coming to understand what good business it is to appeal to increasingly diverse markets? Like Mirabels prognosticating Uncle Bruno, were overwhelmed with an undeniably dire future. With all of her control and push for perfection, Abuela never gave herself a chance to grieve all that she lost, her trauma becoming the reason the Madrigal family would lose everything. She could represent a Mary figure. But her singing isn't great and that almost works in a way. Abuelas trauma of losing her husband and having to flee her home has been a driving force in her controlling nature when it comes to the family's magic. Mi Encanto, Colombia is fun but mostly serves as a transition track. It also strengthens her character and emphasizes her role as the one who can heal the cracks. You're looking for depth and realism in modern Disney? This episode is sponsored by BetterHelp. Except Mirabel, of course. Under the surface, "Encanto . Upload or insert images from URL. "Encanto" tells the tale of an extraordinary family, the Madrigals, who live hidden in the mountains of Colombia, in a magical house, in a vibrant town, in a wondrous, charmed place called an Encanto. And then there's Bruno in family psychology, Bruno is what would be referred to as the "scapegoat", or the person in the family blamed for causing all of the family's problems while actually doing no such thing. Mirabel is miraculously psychologically unscathed despite her long-standing dealings with inadequacy and the cumulative effects of unrealistic expectations (whichgoes For Luisa and Isabelle, as well). In the eyes of the family, Bruno only brought about dark days and bad news with his visions. This subreddit does NOT tolerate or condone ANY form of hate speech, even if thinly veiled or joking. Family member like Luisa, Bruno or Peppa would be a lot more better without them. Integration and thematic cohesion aside, Encanto has hands down the most creative, energetic and dynamic musical sequences I've seen in a musical in a very, very long time. The magic is more related to personal strengths and failings. The Problem with "Encanto" Years of emotional abuse cannot be undone with a song. he is very dreamy but he is not the sun. That quest to save her beloved house makes Encanto not just a story set in Colombia, but about Colombia as well. I understand that in animation, and in cinema in general, some compromises must be made, because there is only so much time in which to tell a story.